Late this summer, Rev. Joe Monahan took on the top stewardship job for the United Methodist Church, following in the footsteps of Rev. Dr. Ken Sloane. I was excited to get to know Joe and find out why he’s passionate about stewardship and generosity. He also offers some great advice. Let’s get going!
Why this job and why now?
After serving local churches for almost 25 years, one thing I discovered about myself is that I enjoy this dimension of ministry and am pretty good at it. Maybe because my background is in engineering, I have always loved the numbers part of ministry – budgets, planning, and evaluation. All of that came naturally. The art of preaching, teaching, and communicating about giving developed more gradually. In the end, what I learned is that it’s about telling the story of God’s goodness and work in, through, and around us – based in gift and not guilt.
Why now? One of the things I love about being a local church pastor is that you are, by necessity, a generalist. But there are these moments when your curiosity pushes you to dive deeper into something. And I felt like I was at that moment in my life and ministry – wanting a new challenge where I could learn new things and help others in new ways, and eager to see my beloved UMC from a different perspective. So I started an MBA and a new job at the same time! It took a lot of praying for me to consider General Agency work – because I had always been hyper-focused on the local church and my own annual conference (Greater New Jersey). But every day, I learn something new about the mission and ministry of the UMC and its people, and for that I’m grateful.
What do you think are the top three stewardship issues facing mainline churches today?
Top three or top 30? There are a lot of challenges right now. I don’t know a pastor or finance chair who doesn’t sometimes feel anxious about money.
First, there’s the issue of engagement around discipleship as a whole – not just giving, but worship, personal devotional practice, small groups, and mission. Increasingly, the conversation I hear people having is that “we don’t have a stewardship problem; we have a discipleship problem.” What we know is that people who are actively engaged in their spiritual life are much more likely to support the ministry of the church. This is good news for pastors, because most of us feel much more comfortable talking about following Jesus. The bad news is that we need models of discipleship that can engage people today.
Second, our buildings often feel more like a liability than a blessing right now. Most of them are at least 50 years old and are due for serious maintenance and renovation. In many cases, they’re too big for our current needs. So reimagining space, partnering with other community organizations, and even redeveloping our buildings for the things communities actually need them to be today is an important challenge and one that I hope general agencies, annual conferences, and other organizations can help churches solve.
Third is the need for churches and pastors to be intentional about planned giving. There is a vast amount of wealth transferring between generations right now. A few simple communications strategies to encourage people to remember the church in their estate plans can make a big difference over time. We often think very narrowly about who might be in a position to leave gifts to the church – the very wealthy, folks with no children, etc. But why wouldn’t we ask everyone who gives during their lifetime to consider a legacy gift? If it matters enough to them that they give every year, why wouldn’t they also remember the church in their will? It doesn’t need to be a $500,000 bequest to be meaningful. If $5,000 or $10,000 gifts arrive steadily and are invested well, they can make a huge difference in the church’s future.
There are lots of small congregations, many in rural areas. What are some generosity tips you might give them?
Well, this is true for all churches, but even more so when you are small. Stop thinking in terms of the annual campaign as the be-all end-all. Instead, do stewardship communication throughout the year. Send the statements, write the letters, highlight the good you are doing in the community. Tell a story about someone the church helped. Be intentional about thanking those who give. Write thank you cards. Take people to lunch and share the vision for ministry. Invite lay people to present a short talk on giving in the worship service. Have them share something about why they love the church or who taught them to give.
A lot of small, rural churches are deeply connected to the community. So don’t just limit your giving messages to the congregation – engage other constituencies who look to the church for support. Leave giving flyers in the fellowship hall for outside groups to find, talk about your ministry to the community and solicit gifts on social media. Actively participate in community events to raise your profile. Every connection we make builds momentum and helps generate energy around the church’s mission.
What’s one thing a congregation can do to help them be more generous?
I believe in the idea of audacious goals as steppingstones that shift attitudes around generosity. Say you’re a small church, and you want to support a mission effort to help people outside the church. For your congregation, maybe $5,000 feels like a real leap of faith. Now imagine that with lots of prayer and planning, buy-in from the leadership, and consistent communications, you get there. I guarantee that if you put in the work to involve the whole congregation, and allow God to meet you in that process, the church will grow in unity and faith. And as a result, you’ll have a God-experience that you can keep pointing to that will help folks move beyond the scarcity mentality toward an understanding of God’s abundance and provision.
What kinds of things do you see your office doing to support the stewardship/generosity work of the church?
Of course, like my predecessor, I’ll be doing things like blogging, preparing publications and resources, connecting via email newsletters and social media, teaching online and in person. That’s the day-to-day work. I’m also really happy to connect with folks in local churches – you can give them my email and encourage them to reach out.
I also want to connect with others doing stewardship ministry – to learn from them, to talk about what people are experiencing in local churches. One thing that I talk about with colleagues from the other General Agencies with overlap in my area (GCFA & UMCom) is that we need to build central hubs where local churches can find tools for doing the ministry of stewardship and generosity well.
There’s also a need to move the conversation beyond white suburban churches into more diverse contexts: African American, Korean, Hispanic/Latino, and rural churches. Discipleship Ministries is tasked with serving the whole Connection – so that means engaging theologies and practices of stewardship from across the globe.
What are a couple of your favorite stewardship books?
I’m still partial to the J. Clif Christopher classic Rich Church Poor Church, mainly because it was one of the first stewardship books that began to reshape my thinking. It’s also very accessible for discussion with church finance leaders. More recently, I might point to Generosity, Stewardship, and Abundance by Lovett Weems and Ann Michel as a primer on all phases of this ministry. One of my tasks in this first year is to survey the recent literature in the field, plus revisiting some of Wesley’s sermons on money. Check back in a year from now and I may have a different answer!
What’s giving you hope these days?
I still believe in local church. I know a lot of congregations are struggling, but I also believe that God is up to something, especially in the lives of young people. In my last appointment, I was seeing high school students starting Bible studies in each other’s homes – in New Jersey! Who would believe that? I continue to see churches and congregations doing the faithful work of ministry in their communities – faithfully sharing the Word and stepping up to care for people. God is not done with us!
Do you have one story that sticks out to you that illustrates the beauty of generosity?
The church I served before entering this appointment built a new building during my time there. It was a project the church had been dreaming of since the church moved its physical location in the 1970s. The congregation had hoped to construct a larger fellowship hall but the move split the church and the money just wasn’t there. From the 2000s into the 2010s, the congregation ran multiple capital campaigns, but prices kept escalating and the project seemed like it would be forever out of reach. Many weren’t hopeful.
When I arrived, I found a single dollar in a frame, hung up in the office. It was given by a little boy in the church, and we kept it for years – the first dollar ever given to the building campaign. It was a sign of hope and promise. When we finally dedicated the building in 2017, we invited this boy – now a college graduate, still active in the church’s ministry – to come and be part of the dedication. It was a full-circle moment that illustrated God’s faithfulness through the journey of a child’s offering.
Anything else you’d like to add?
I just want to say thanks for your ministry, Cesie – it’s really important. I look forward to working with you and hearing from your readers. I would love to hear more about what people need from Discipleship Ministries’ stewardship offerings. Please feel free to reach out at jmonahan@umcdiscipleship.org, bookmark umcdiscipleship.org/stewardship, and follow us on social media.
###
Thank you, Joe for this interview. As anyone who has been in a new job knows, there is so much to learn. I appreciate you taking the time to share your wisdom and knowledge with my favorite Inspiring Generosity readers. I’m excited to be working with you!
P.S. A great grant opportunity: The Lily Endowment is awarding grants of up to $5 million each to up to 60 charitable organizations for “Serving Neighbors Through Congregational Collaborations.” Concept papers are due January 19, 2027.
Cesie Delve Scheuermann (pronounced “CC Delv Sherman,” yes, really) is a Stewardship Consultant for the OR-ID Annual Conference. She is also a Senior Ministry Strategist with Horizons Stewardship – helping with capital campaigns and encouraging more generosity. For 25 years, while working as a volunteer and part-time consultant, she has helped raise millions of dollars for numerous churches and non-profit organizations. She’s giving a two-thumbs up enthusiastic review for the new Laika movie, Wildwood. An amazing artistic achievement.
You can reach Cesie at inspiringgenerosity@gmail.com, at CesieScheuermann.com, or at cesieds@horizons.net. Want to schedule a meeting? She’s got you covered!
Schedule a meeting now.
If someone has forwarded this to you and you would like to subscribe to "Inspiring Generosity," click here. Miss an issue? Click here